Muddy Waters Oyster Bar Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Muddy Waters Oyster Bar in Pittsburgh, PA offers a unique dining experience with a Cajun/Creole and seafood menu. The restaurant provides a range of amenities including reservations, takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating. Known for its lively ambiance and friendly service, customers rave about the grilled oysters, hush puppies, and Mac 'N' Cheese. The menu features dishes like Fried Alligator, Catfish Sticks, and Chargrilled Oysters, showcasing a blend of Southern flavors. The cocktail selection is extensive, with creative options like the Marigny Monsieur and West coast shot. Whether you're in for brunch or dinner, Muddy Waters is a go-to spot for fresh seafood and well-crafted cocktails. Don't miss out on their delicious offerings and hospitable atmosphere.

Brunch Family Dinner for 2 Starters Sandwich Shop Snacks and Small Plates Large Plates

Brunch

Fried chicken and biscuits

Sunny side up egg, country sausage gravy, house pickles
$17.00

Brunch Shrimp Po Boy

Fried Shrimp, Bacon, Egg, Iceberg, Tomato, Pickle,Chili Mayo
$20.00

Brunch Oyster Po Boy

Fried Oysters, Bacon, Egg, Iceberg, Tomato, Pickle,Chili Mayo
$20.00

Breakfast Sandwich

Breakfast Sandwich on a house made buttermilk biscuit with american cheese, fried egg and your choice of protein
$7.00

Beignets

with Chocolate Sauce
$7.00

Gator Po Boy

Blackened Gator, Fried Green Tomato,Collard Greens Slaw, Pimento Cheese
$20.00

Cajun Fries
$3.50

Family Dinner

Pick 1 starter, 1 main dish and 2 sides
$40.00

Family Dinner for 2

Starters

Sweet Potato Corn Bread

Weatherbury farm cornmeal, housemade local apple butter and hot honey.
$10.00

Fried Alligator

Chipotle aioli.
$13.50

Catfish Sticks

Abita purple haze beer batter and remoulade.
$9.00

Mac 'N' Cheese

Peppadew, seasoned breadcrumbs and fresh herbs.
$10.00

Foie Gras Deviled Eggs

Bacon jam and smoked trout roe.
$12.50

Hush Puppies

Corn, scallions, dill and remoulade.
$9.00

Fried Green Tomatoes

Pimento cheese and collard greens slaw.
$11.00

Chargrilled Oysters

Garlic butter, Parmesan and chili flakes.
$15.00

Classic Po Boy

Choice of fried shrimp or oysters (peacemaker: get both mixed for an additional charge), iceberg, tomato, house dill pickles and chili mayo.
$17.50

Alligator Po Boy

Blackened gator, fried green tomato, collard greens slaw and pimento cheese.
$20.00

Cajun Style Reuben

Cajun seasoned corned beef, marble rye bread, Swiss cheese, collard green sauerkraut remoulade and house dill pickles.
$16.50

Louisiana Lobster Roll

Maine lobster and crawfish, garlic butter, lemon and split top roll.
$24.00

Da Lil Chunky Burger

2 patties, fried green tomato, American, Benton's bacon, sunny side up egg, chili mayo, iceberg and house dill pickles.
$15.50

Sandwich Shop

Snacks and Small Plates

Red Beans and Rice

Red Bean n Rice
$6.60

Gator and Sausage Gumbo Plate

Dark roux, okra and white rice.
$10.00

Smoked Boudin Plate

Assorted pickled items, creole mustard aioli and Cajun dill potato chips.
$11.00

Iceberg Wedge Salad

Smoked bleu, bacon, egg, radish, pickled green tomato and buttermilk ranch.
$9.00

Spring Salad

Spring Mix Greens, Shaved Asparagus, Green Peas, Radish, Shaved Red Onion, Avocado Green Goddess Dressing
$13.50

6 wings

6 fried wings with 1 sauce and 1 choice of flavor.
$6.60

12 wings

12 fried wings with 1 sauce and 1 choice of flavor.
$13.20

Seafood Gumbo Plate

Gulf shrimp, crawfish, oysters, catfish, andouille sausage, okra and white rice.
$26.00

Jambalaya Plate

Chicken, andouille sausage, shrimp, white rice and creole tomato broth.
$27.00

Creole Shrimp and Grits Plate

Gulf shrimp, Nora Mills cheddar grits, trinity, tasso ham, shrimp stock and heirloom tomato.
$28.00

STEAK FRITES

14oz New York Strip,Mushroom Bourbon au Poivre,Truffle Parmesan Fries
$35.00

NASHVILLE STYLE HOT CHICKEN

Nora Mills Cheddar Grits,Pork Braised Creamed Collards,House Sweet Pickles
$29.00

Large Plates